Secret Origins ##44
DC Comics • Secret Origins Vol. 2
Writer
Alan Grant
Interior Artist
Dick Giordano
Cover Artist
Kevin Nowlan
Publication Date
September 1989
Cover Variant
Regular Edition
Printing
First Printing
Comic Description
Part 1 of the 'Mud Pack' storyline. This issue explores the origins of the various Clayfaces (Basil Karlo, Matt Hagen, Preston Payne, and Sondra Fuller) as they unite to destroy Batman.
Condition & Value
Condition Grade
Very Fine- (CGC 7.5)
Condition Details
Visible spine stress marks and color-breaking ticks on the left edge. Mild corner blunting on the top and bottom left. Minor edge wear on the top right. Slight surface scuffing visible on the dark purple background.
Estimated Market Value
Raw: $5 - $15 | Graded (9.8): $60 - $80
Recent Sales
Raw copies typically sell for $5-10; recent CGC 9.8 sales have averaged around $75. Low demand for mid-grade copies.
Grading Recommendation
Not recommended for professional grading. The fair market value in this condition does not justify the grading fees. Only worth grading if it was a guaranteed 9.8.
Notable Features
Features the origin of the Mud Pack. Tie-in prologue to Detective Comics #604. Modern Copper Age key for Clayface fans.
Authentication Notes
Authentic direct edition copy. Paper stock and ink density are consistent with 1989 DC Comics manufacturing. No signs of reproduction or tampering.