Batman ##159
DC Comics • Batman Vol. 1
Writer
Bill Finger
Interior Artist
Sheldon Moldoff
Cover Artist
Sheldon Moldoff
Publication Date
November 1963
Cover Variant
Regular/A Cover
Printing
First Printing
Comic Description
Features the story 'The Great Clayface-Joker Feud!' where the second Clayface (Matt Hagen) impersonates the Joker to commit crimes. This issue creates a significant crossover between two major Batman villains. It also includes an 'Imaginary Story' backup titled 'The Boyhood of Bruce Wayne Jr.'
Condition & Value
Condition Grade
Very Good (CGC 4.0)
Condition Details
Moderate spine stress and potential rolling; corner blunting visible on all corners; noticeable yellowing/tanning of the cover and interior edges typical of Silver Age books; minor edge wear and surface scuffing visible through the poly-bag.
Estimated Market Value
Raw: $35 - $60; Graded (CGC 4.0): $100 - $140
Recent Sales
Recent sales for mid-grade copies (VG/FN) range from $45 to $75. Higher grade copies (VF 8.0+) can exceed $300.
Grading Recommendation
Generally not recommended for professional grading unless the interior is exceptionally white. The cost of grading (shipment, fees) might equal the raw market value, though a CGC slab would preserve it.
Notable Features
Second appearance of Matt Hagen as Clayface; Joker guest appearance; Sheldon Moldoff iconic 1960s Batman art style; Silver Age DC 12-cent price variant.
Authentication Notes
The wear pattern, paper oxidation (yellowing), and 12c price point are consistent with authentic copies from 1963. Staple placement and 'National Comics' logo check out for the era.