Astonishing X-Men ##5

Marvel Comics • Astonishing X-Men Vol. 3

Astonishing X-Men

Writer

Joss Whedon

Interior Artist

John Cassaday

Cover Artist

John Cassaday

Publication Date

October 2004

Cover Variant

Regular

Printing

First Printing

Comic Description

Part of Joss Whedon and John Cassaday's acclaimed 'Gifted' storyline, dealing with the fallout of a mutant cure and escalating tensions involving SWORD, Ord, and the X-Men.

Condition & Value

Condition Grade

Very Fine (CGC 8.0)

Condition Details

Moderate spine stress ticks, minor corner blunting, slight edge wear along the top edge, and minor scuffing on the dark cover stock.

Estimated Market Value

Raw value: $5 - $15. Graded CGC 9.4/9.6 value: $30 - $50.

Recent Sales

Recent raw sales for Astonishing X-Men #5 range between $5 and $12 depending on platform and specific condition.

Grading Recommendation

Not generally recommended for professional grading unless part of a full run submission, as the raw value and potential grade (around Fine/Very Fine to Very Fine) would not recoup the cost of encapsulation.

Notable Features

Direct Edition with barcode box, part of the fan-favorite Whedon/Cassaday run that redefined the X-Men in the 2000s.

Authentication Notes

Standard Marvel Direct Edition from the mid-2000s with correct paper stock, standard barcode, and publisher indicia matching known print runs.

Scanned on 11/3/2026