Action Comics ##254
DC Comics • Action Comics Vol. 1
Writer
Otto Binder
Interior Artist
Al Plastino (Superman story), Jim Mooney (Supergirl story)
Cover Artist
Curt Swan (pencils), Stan Kaye (inks)
Publication Date
July 1959
Cover Variant
Regular/A Cover
Printing
First Printing
Comic Description
Features the story 'The Battle with Bizarro!' where Superman faces off against his imperfect duplicate. It also includes a Supergirl feature, 'The Supergirl from Krypton!', which is the second appearance of Supergirl (Kara Zor-El).
Condition & Value
Condition Grade
Very Good (CGC 4.0)
Condition Details
Visible foxing and tanning throughout the yellow areas of the front cover. Minor color-breaking creases along the bottom edge. Significant corner blunting and minor spine stress. Small tear visible on the bottom left corner near the edge.
Estimated Market Value
Raw: $80 - $120; Graded (CGC 4.0): $150 - $200
Recent Sales
Recent 2024 sales for CGC 4.0 copies range between $160 and $190. Raw mid-grade copies frequently trade around the $100 mark depending on eye appeal.
Grading Recommendation
Moderate recommendation. While a key Silver Age issue, the heavy tanning and foxing may limit the grade. Professional pressing and cleaning might improve surface stains but won't fix structural integrity. Grade if submitting a larger lot for authentication.
Notable Features
Second appearance of Supergirl. Early Silver Age key issue. Iconic Bizarro cover appearance. 10-cent original cover price.
Authentication Notes
Authentic copy from 1959. Exhibits correct paper aging/tanning for the era, period-correct 'Superman DC National Comics' seal, and standard 10-cent branding.