What If...? ##74

Marvel Comics • What If...? Vol. 2

What If...?

Writer

Simon Furman

Interior Artist

Geoff Isherwood

Cover Artist

Geoff Isherwood

Publication Date

June 1995

Cover Variant

Direct Edition

Printing

First Printing

Comic Description

Explores an alternate universe where Mr. Sinister successfully formed the X-Men instead of Professor Charles Xavier, leading to a much darker and more aggressive mutant team.

Condition & Value

Condition Grade

Very Good (CGC 4.0)

Condition Details

Heavy roll on the spine, significant spine stress, heavy creasing on the top right corner and across the cover, blunted corners, and general surface wear.

Estimated Market Value

Raw: $3 - $6; Graded: Not recommended for professional grading.

Recent Sales

Recent raw sales range from $2 to $5 depending on the platform.

Grading Recommendation

Not worth grading. The cost of professional slab and shipping would far exceed the market value of the book in this condition.

Notable Features

Features an alternate timeline team consisting of villains and anti-heroes like Sabretooth, and includes the tagline 'These are NOT your father's superheroes...'.

Authentication Notes

Appears to be an authentic 1990s direct edition print with standard newsprint interior and cardstock cover of the era.

Scanned on 10/21/2026
What If...? ##74 - Marvel Comics | Comic Book Scanner