What If...? ##76

Marvel ComicsWhat If...? Vol. 2

What If...?

Writer

Simon Furman

Interior Artist

Sergio Cariello

Cover Artist

Sergio Cariello

Publication Date

August 1995

Cover Variant

Direct Edition

Printing

First Printing

Comic Description

Explores the alternate scenario where Peter Parker had to destroy Spider-Man, featuring the final appearance of The Watcher in the pages of What If!.

Condition & Value

Condition Grade

Near Mint- (CGC 9.2)

Condition Details

Very minor shelf wear, light spine stress near the top staple, sharp corners, flat cover with good gloss.

Estimated Market Value

Raw: $5 - $15 | Graded (CGC 9.2/9.4): $30 - $50

Recent Sales

Recent raw copies have sold in the $5 to $12 range on eBay depending on shipping and exact condition.

Grading Recommendation

Not generally recommended for professional grading unless part of a bulk submission, as the raw value is relatively low and grading fees would exceed the market value increase.

Notable Features

Final appearance of The Watcher in the series, part of the 'All-New What If!' relaunch featuring the Marvel Alterniverse logo.

Authentication Notes

Appears to be an authentic 1990s direct edition comic with standard paper stock, correct barcode box, and publisher logos consistent with Marvel publications from August 1995.

Scanned on 8/10/2026