The Girl in the Bay ##2

Dark Horse Comics (Berger Books)The Girl in the Bay #2 of 4

The Girl in the Bay

Writer

J.M. DeMatteis

Interior Artist

Corin Howell

Cover Artist

Corin Howell

Publication Date

March 2019

Cover Variant

Regular/A Cover

Printing

First Printing

Comic Description

In 1969, Kathy Sartori was attacked and thrown into Brooklyn's Sheepshead Bay. She emerges 50 years later, having not aged a day, to find another woman living her life. In issue #2, Kathy continues to explore her displacement in time and the supernatural mystery of the 'resurrection.'

Condition & Value

Condition Grade

Near Mint (CGC 9.4)

Condition Details

Minimum visible wear on the edges, sharp corners, and a flat cover. Minor potential for spine ticking visible upon extremely close inspection of the left edge near the bottom. Staples appear well-seated without tearing.

Estimated Market Value

$3.00 - $6.00 (Raw); $30.00 - $45.00 (9.8 Graded)

Recent Sales

Recent sales for raw copies typically hover around cover price ($3.99). High-grade graded copies rarely appear on auction but follow modern indie book trends of low liquid volume.

Grading Recommendation

Not recommended for professional grading. The cost of the grading service (approx. $25-$40) significantly exceeds the market value of the book. It is best kept in a bag and board for personal enjoyment.

Notable Features

Part of the 'Berger Books' imprint edited by Karen Berger; features a supernatural mystery theme by veteran writer J.M. DeMatteis.

Authentication Notes

The book shows high-quality modern gloss finish, correct Dark Horse/Berger Books logo placement, and standard modern industrial staple placement. No signs of restoration or reproduction.

Scanned on 5/26/2026