What If...? ##76

Marvel Comics • What If...? Vol. 2

What If...?

Writer

Simon Furman

Interior Artist

Jeff Matsuda

Cover Artist

Carlos Pacheco

Publication Date

August 1995

Cover Variant

Regular Direct Edition

Printing

First Printing

Comic Description

Explores the alternate reality where Peter Parker had to destroy Spider-Man, featuring a storyline asking what if the clone or symbiote/suit trauma went a different route, highlighted by a bold promotional callout on the cover.

Condition & Value

Condition Grade

Very Good (CGC 4.0)

Condition Details

Noticeable roll on the spine, heavy spine stress ticks along the left edge, corner blunting and creasing at top and bottom corners, overall cover wear with faint scuffing, and minor edge bending.

Estimated Market Value

Raw: $3.00 - $6.00, Graded (CGC 4.0): $15.00 - $25.00

Recent Sales

Recent raw sales for mid-to-low grade copies of 1990s What If issues generally range between $2.00 and $5.00 depending on platform and shipping.

Grading Recommendation

Not worth professional grading. The grading and slab fees would far outweigh the market value of the comic in a lower grade like Very Good.

Notable Features

Features a prominent callout bubble on the cover advertising the 'Final Appearance of The Watcher in the pages of What If!'. Direct edition copy with barcode box.

Authentication Notes

Appears authentic with standard 1990s newsprint/glossy cover stock, correct Marvel indicia, UPC barcode box, and traditional coloring styles consistent with mid-90s Marvel publications.

Scanned on 10/21/2026